Spinal versus general anesthesia for hip fracture
Does anesthetic technique change delirium, survival, or recovery after hip-fracture surgery? Examine randomized comparisons, sedation protocols, crossover, and the populations enrolled.
Published studies
Open in feedRecent evidence appears first, ordered by publication date. Earlier evidence and papers without precise dates follow separately. Design categories are inferred from PubMed metadata, not evidence grades.
Showing 3 of 6 · Other
Recent evidence · past year
-
General anesthesia is associated with increased postoperative morbidity and mortality in frail patients undergoing hip fracture fixation.
AI summary of the abstract, unverified
- Retrospective ACS-NSQIP analysis (2015–2020) of frail hip fracture fixation patients, with 24,401 under general anesthesia and 6,193 under spinal.
- The exposure was general versus spinal anesthesia, with frailty classified by the 5-item modified Frailty Index.
- On multivariable regression, general anesthesia was linked to higher odds of mortality, unplanned readmission, and all complications in frail patients; the abstract gives no effect sizes or CIs.
- The authors suggest spinal anesthesia may be safer and that frail patients under general anesthesia may benefit from more postoperative monitoring.
Original abstract (PubMed)
INTRODUCTION: Anesthetic management of hip fracture fixation has two primary modalities: general anesthesia (GA) and spinal anesthesia (SA). Choice of anesthesia often depends on institutional protocols and the individual anesthesiologist, due to a lack of consensus guidelines. Most studies have conflicting evidence and focus primarily on elderly age as a risk factor, without accounting for frailty. This study investigates whether frailty influences the relationship between anesthetic modality and postoperative outcomes. METHODS: This retrospective study queried the ACS-NSQIP from 2015 to 2020 for patients who underwent hip fracture fixation with open reduction internal fixation with plate and screws or intramedullary implant insertion. Patients were separated based on whether they received GA or SA. Frailty was evaluated using the 5-Item Modified Frailty Index (mFI-5). Patients classified as frail or severely frail were included. Multivariable regression adjusting for age, sex, ASA classification, smoking, and the comorbidities significant on univariate regression was performed. The outcomes examined were mortality, unplanned readmission, and overall complications within 30 days postoperatively. RESULTS: This study included 24,401 patients under GA and 6193 patients under SA. On multivariable regression analysis, GA was independently associated with increased odds of mortality, unplanned readmission, and all complications among frail patients. Severely frail patients under GA had increased odds of unplanned readmission and all complications. When looking at both frail and severely frail patients together, GA remained a significant predictor of mortality, unplanned readmission, and all complications. DISCUSSION: After controlling for ASA classification, our study found that frail and severely frail patients undergoing GA for hip fracture fixation had significantly increased odds of mortality, unplanned readmission, and all complications. Our findings suggest that SA may be safer compared to GA in frail patients undergoing hip fracture fixation. Frail patients that undergo GA may benefit from increased postoperative monitoring to help mitigate complications.
-
Do-not-resuscitate status and regional analgesia utilization for fracture pain: a comfort paradox?
AI summary of the abstract, unverified
- Cross-sectional analysis of National Inpatient Sample adult hospitalizations for rib or hip fractures from 2016 to 2022, including 298,343 rib and 462,796 hip fracture admissions.
- Compares receipt of regional analgesia by do-not-resuscitate status; regional analgesia was received in 2.9% of rib and 3.0% of hip fracture hospitalizations.
- Do-not-resuscitate status was linked to lower adjusted odds of regional analgesia for rib fractures (OR 0.76; 95% CI 0.69 to 0.83) but not hip fractures (OR 1.00; 95% CI 0.94 to 1.06).
- The association was strongest among the least frail rib fracture hospitalizations (OR 0.34; 95% CI 0.25 to 0.48), and the authors call for prospective studies to confirm the findings.
Original abstract (PubMed)
BACKGROUND: Do-not-resuscitate orders are intended to prioritize patient comfort, but do-not-resuscitate patients may receive fewer procedural interventions. Regional analgesia is recommended for rib and hip fractures and may provide superior pain control to systemic analgesics. However, utilization remains low. Whether do-not-resuscitate status is associated with the utilization of comfort-enhancing regional analgesia has not been studied. METHODS: This was a cross-sectional study using the National Inpatient Sample of adult (≥18 years) hospitalizations for rib and hip fractures identified using International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision codes from January 1, 2016, through December 31, 2022. The primary exposure was do-not-resuscitate status. The primary outcome was receipt of regional analgesia. RESULTS: 298,343 rib fracture and 462,796 hip fracture hospitalizations met inclusion criteria, of which 8,568 (2.9%) and 13,730 (3.0%) received regional analgesia, respectively. Do-not-resuscitate status was present in 31,882 (10.7%) of rib fracture and 77,255 (16.7%) hip fracture hospitalizations.In adjusted analyses, do-not-resuscitate status was associated with lower odds of regional analgesia for rib fractures (OR 0.76; 95% CI 0.69 to 0.83), but not hip fractures (OR 1.00; 95% CI 0.94 to 1.06). In frailty-stratified analyses, the association between do-not-resuscitate status and lower rates of regional analgesia utilization was strongest among the least frail rib fracture hospitalizations (OR 0.34; 95% CI 0.25 to 0.48). CONCLUSIONS: Do-not-resuscitate status is associated with lower regional analgesia utilization for rib fractures but not hip fractures. Prospective studies are needed to confirm these findings.
-
Anaesthetic challenges in a nonagenarian with Parkinson's disease undergoing hip fracture surgery: a case report.
AI summary of the abstract, unverified
- Single case report of one 93-year-old man with Parkinson's disease who underwent cemented hemiarthroplasty for a hip fracture, with a Newari-only language barrier.
- Spinal anaesthesia used 3 mL of 0.5% hyperbaric bupivacaine with 5 µg intrathecal dexmedetomidine, chosen to prolong the block after discussion with the orthopaedic team.
- Intraoperative hypotension (three episodes, treated with mephentermine) and hypoglycaemia (55 mg/dL) occurred, followed by transient delirium and aspiration pneumonia; discharged on postoperative day 10.
- The authors conclude spinal anaesthesia was feasible and emphasise dose optimisation, glycaemic monitoring, continuing dopaminergic therapy, delirium prevention, and dysphagia-safe feeding.
Original abstract (PubMed)
BACKGROUND: Hip fractures in nonagenarian patients with multiple comorbidities present substantial anaesthetic challenges. Parkinson's disease (PD) adds further complexity through motor symptoms, autonomic dysfunction, and the imperative for uninterrupted dopaminergic therapy. CASE PRESENTATION: We report the perioperative anaesthetic management of a 93-year-old male with hypertension, Parkinson's disease, hypothyroidism, and dyslipidaemia who underwent cemented left hemiarthroplasty for a transcervical neck of femur fracture. The case was additionally complicated by a significant language barrier, as the patient was exclusively fluent in Newari. Spinal anaesthesia was administered at L3-L4 using 3 mL of 0.5% hyperbaric bupivacaine with 5 µg intrathecal dexmedetomidine, selected to prolong anaesthesia based on discussion with the orthopaedic team; the rationale and limitations of this dosing strategy are critically appraised in the Discussion. Intraoperatively, the patient developed three episodes of hypotension, likely related to sympathetic blockade and adjuvant effects, managed with incremental doses of mephentermine. An episode of intraoperative hypoglycaemia (blood glucose 55 mg/dL) was promptly corrected with 50% dextrose. Postoperatively, the patient developed transient hypoactive delirium due to temporary interruption of dopaminergic therapy, which resolved after resumption of enteral medications by postoperative day 2. On postoperative day 3, the patient developed aspiration pneumonia after oral feeding was initiated by family members despite a functioning nasogastric tube. The condition was managed with antibiotics and supportive care. The patient subsequently improved and was discharged on postoperative day 10. CONCLUSION: Spinal anaesthesia is feasible in nonagenarians with multiple comorbidities, including Parkinson's disease. This case highlights the need for evidence-based dose optimisation and proactive complication prevention. It further emphasises the importance of low-dose bupivacaine-based spinal anaesthesia in very elderly patients, meticulous perioperative glycaemic monitoring, continuation of dopaminergic therapy, structured delirium prevention strategies, caregiver education, and strict adherence to dysphagia-safe feeding protocols in high-risk geriatric patients.
Earlier evidence / dates not confirmed
Includes older studies, year-only dates, and future-dated records. Inclusion does not imply landmark status.
- No matching papers in this section with the selected filters.
Ongoing registrations
From ClinicalTrials.govRegistrations, not results. These registry entries describe ongoing studies, not their findings. They are not counted as published evidence above; check linked records for updates and associated publications.
No registered ongoing trials found.